A few weeks ago I got an email I’ve now received some version of dozens of times. I’ll paraphrase to protect the person who sent it, but I’m not changing the temperature:
I think I’ve believed a lie my whole life. Evangelical Christianity has been the center of who I am — my family, my friendships, my sense of vocation, how I parent, the way I read every part of my own life. And now I have so many questions about its history, its agenda, its intellectual credibility that I don’t know how to keep believing it. I don’t know who I am without this faith. I also don’t know how to keep holding it. I am terrified.
These emails come most weeks now. The names change. The denominations change. The specific doctrine that broke first changes — sometimes it’s hell, sometimes it’s six-day creation, sometimes it’s what the pastor said about queer people, sometimes it’s the slow recognition that the Bible they were told was a single seamless garment has more authors and more arguments stitched into it than they were ever permitted to see. Sometimes it isn’t a doctrine that broke first at all. Sometimes it’s an experience of trauma, betrayal, or shame in a community that called itself the body of Christ.
But the panic underneath is always the same shape. It’s the panic of someone who suspects they were lied to about the most important thing in their life — and who can’t tell the difference between the thing they were told about and the thing itself.
I have been this person. More than once.
I’ve lain awake with the suspicion that everything I’d built my life on was structurally unsound. I’ve stood in pulpits and said words I no longer believed in the way I’d been taught to believe them — or, more honestly, in the way I knew the people listening were going to hear them. I’ve driven home from church and panicked in the car. I’ve wondered whether the move from certainty to honesty was going to cost me my faith, my friends, my livelihood, or all three. Some weeks I thought it would. Most weeks now, I’m convinced it didn’t.
So when this email lands in my inbox, I don’t read it as a stranger writing to me. I read it as a younger version of myself, asking the question I was once too scared to ask out loud.
Here is the thing I wish someone had told me when I was where they are.
What if what’s dying isn’t your faith?
What if it’s just your idea of what your faith was?
Your conception of someone you love is not the someone you love. When the conception dies, the relationship doesn’t. It can actually deepen.
I’ve been married longer than I’ve been single, and the hardest thing in a long relationship is giving the other person permission to be themselves — not the version I have in my head, not the version I’d prefer, not the Tripp’s-preferred-edit of who they ought to be. The actual person. Their real self is a mystery I don’t own and can’t fully know. And keeping that distance — between my idea of her and who she actually is — turns out to be essential for love. It’s what gives her permission to be herself, which is the only way she can return the favor and let me be myself.
Same with my kids. I’ve thought I knew what they wanted and been wrong for years. Sometimes the misread is small. Buddy, I made you your favorite breakfast. — Dad, I don’t actually like it. I just like that you make it for me. I would have made something else if I’d known. The whole point was to send him to school fed, and to be someone he could see was on his team. But his fear of disappointing me kept him from letting me know him. That sentence has stayed with me longer than the breakfast did.
When you update your understanding of a person, you’re not falsifying the relationship. You’re getting closer to who they actually are. The picture breaking is intimacy.
You are not losing God. You are losing a conception of God. A conception you were handed when you were fourteen by people who loved you and thought they were giving you the whole picture as best they could — and which you were never given permission to revise. That conception did real work in your life. It guided real love. It is not a lie. It is a picture. And like every picture of someone you love, it has always been partial.
The God who is actually there has always been more than the picture. By definition.
Mystery isn’t a deficit. It’s the precondition for being known at all.
A chasing understanding can be painful. It is also how love has always worked.
I have done this several times now. It doesn’t get easier exactly, but the first time you survive it, you start to recognize what’s happening. When you set aside the first full, intact, certified picture, your faith isn’t dying. Your belief might be — at least for a while. But that’s the beginning of a different kind of intimacy. You’re not losing God. You’re moving closer.
Here’s where the philosophy of religion shows up to confirm what your gut already knows.
Almost a hundred years ago, the mathematician-turned-philosopher Alfred North Whitehead wrote a book called Religion in the Making. In it he watched the whole arc of human religious history and named what he saw. Religion, he argued, evolves through four phases: ritual, emotion, belief, rationalization.
All four matter. The order they emerged in doesn’t make the first stage the best stage; religion needs all four woven together to be itself. But naming the four creates a diagnostic, and that diagnostic is exactly what makes sense of the deficiency a lot of us have discovered in evangelical Christianity.
The first stage, ritual, was bodies moving together. This was before language, before abstract thought, before the symbolic capacity that lets you have a concept like “God” at all. Bodies in rhythm, in repetition, in the firelight, marking the seasons and the dead. (Yes — our ancestors were religious before they could conjugate a sentence. Sit with that for a moment.)
The second stage, emotion, is the visceral response that ritual generates. The shiver. The tears. The opening of the chest. The thing that happens to you in the singing before you have words for what just happened. Whitehead has a line that has followed me around for years:
Music comes before religion, as emotion comes before thought, and sound before sense.
The third stage, belief, is when stories show up — the myths that personalize the forces of nature, the narratives that make sense of the rituals, the figures who carry the meaning. Belief begins as poetry, not as proposition.
The fourth stage, rationalization, is the late-stage cleanup crew that organizes belief into systems and creeds and dogmas. It’s necessary. It’s what creates the spaciousness for communities to develop a stable, transmittable identity. It is also the stage that, if it forgets where it came from, kills the very thing it was trying to save.
Belief shows up in stage three. Doctrine shows up in stage four. The first three-quarters of the religious story happened before anyone got asked what they think — before anyone felt the burden of defining and defending and policing their beliefs.
The version of Christianity that asks you to believe the right things or be damned is not the whole tradition. It’s the tradition with one stage doing all the work and the other three suppressed, forgotten, or written off as primitive.
And once you see this, you start to notice how strange the contemporary evangelical setup actually is.
At the very heart of the Christian story is a God who has refused to be God without us. A God who poured the divine life into creation, sustained it through covenant, kept showing up to a stiff-necked people, and then became imaged in the fidelity of a Galilean Jewish carpenter to the One he called Abba. Across the entire arc of that story, the divine is doing one thing relentlessly — seeking encounter, intimacy, relationship.
Now imagine standing inside that story and saying: You don’t belong here unless you affirm doctrine X and reject heresy Y.
The God of this story has been chasing humanity across geological time. And one finite, historically contingent group of believers — usually one with very specific eighteenth- or nineteenth-century commitments — gets to decide whether you’re in the relationship?
That’s not the Christian story. That’s a particular and very recent regime laid on top of it.
Belief-centered Christianity is a late, late, late development. Knowing how late, and knowing what came before it, has been one of the most freeing things I’ve learned as a philosopher of religion.
For most of human history — and we’re talking 200,000-plus years, not 2,000 — religion looked like Whitehead’s first two stages. Bodies moving together. Food shared. The dead remembered. The cosmos alive. The earth as kin. Identity wasn’t yours alone; it was something a people did together. The sacred wasn’t above nature but inside it. There was no individual salvation because there was barely an individual yet to save.
This isn’t a primitivist fantasy. Pre-Axial religion had its own brutalities. The point isn’t that they had it right and we have it wrong. The point is that what we now call “religion” is one phase in a much longer story.
Then something cracked open. Roughly 800 to 200 BCE, almost simultaneously and without contact between them, the Hebrew prophets, the Buddha, Socrates, Confucius, and the Upanishadic sages all turned the religious imagination toward something new. The encounter with the sacred shifted toward the individual, the transcendent, the universal. Belief started doing work it had never done before.
The gains were real. Conscience. The prophetic no to power. The recognition of the stranger as neighbor. The capacity to say no to your own tribe in the name of something higher than tribal benefit.
The losses were also real. The body got demoted. The earth became the stage rather than kin. Shared collective identity thinned out. The feminine got written over in tradition after tradition. And the trust that ritual encounter — bodies in the dark, around fire, marking the dead — was already enough started to dissolve.
Then hit the fast-forward button. The Reformation amplified individual belief. Modernity supercharged it — turning every person into a sovereign believer responsible for personally adjudicating whether their God is even real, alongside the suddenly-on-the-table option of no religion at all. American revivalism finished the job by turning faith into a doctrinal exam with hell as the wrong answer.
The version of Christianity whose collapse you are currently feeling is not 2,000 years old. In its current intensity, it’s more like 200.
What you were taught was Christianity is one historically contingent shape of it. A recent shape. A specific shape. Not the only shape. Not the original.
Naming what’s actually dying makes it possible to see what was always the deeper thing — the thing that isn’t under threat by your changing your mind, asking a question, or refusing to stay in a community that shames you.
What’s actually dying:
Certainty as the proof of authentic faith.
Belief as the location of the relationship.
Inerrancy as the foundation everything rests on.
The doctrinal regime that turned faith into a true/false exam.
The version of “Christian” that requires you never to grow.
What was always the deeper thing:
Encounter. The actual presence, the actual relationship — the same encounter every person across every century has been met by.
Practice. Bread broken, water poured, songs sung, bodies kneeling, the dead named. Practices that carry you when your hands cannot hold doctrine.
Belonging. A people that includes the ones who came before and the ones not yet born. A baton you’ve been handed and will hand on.
Mystery. The God who is, by definition, always more than your conception.
Trust.
That last one is the whole thing. Before faith got narrowed into belief — before it got flattened into “assenting to a series of ideas that make you somehow closer to God than the people with different ideas” — faith meant trust. Trust in a mystery you seek to understand and which will always exceed your understanding.
For Christians, the One we trust is the One revealed in Jesus the Christ. The One Jesus called Abba. The loving and faithful, patient and gracious God of justice who seeks to find us in all our humanity — in our brokenness and our pain, in the ways we have harmed others and the harm done to us. That God is worthy of trust. Not because we’ve gotten all the answers right. Not because we hold the right beliefs with the right certainty. Trust is about who you are oriented toward, not what you have decided about them.
When you move beyond belief as the precondition for faith, you are not abandoning faith. You are recovering the older sense of the word.
The most recent email named the fear bluntly. Without certainty, what’s even left to hold onto?
I know what that question feels like. I have felt it. Don’t let anyone — including me — get you to skip past the panic. As hard as it is to hear, the panic is evidence you’re alive in this. You don’t grieve the loss of something you never had.
But name what you’re actually grieving. You are not grieving God. You are grieving a picture of God you got handed in middle school and were never given permission to question.
That picture deserves to be honored, not dismissed. It did real work. It brought you to the place where your love for God is now soliciting the prayer Meister Eckhart taught me to pray:
God, rid me of God.
That is not a prayer for atheism. It is a prayer that captures what is actually happening here. Your idea of God is allowed to break — not so the relationship can end, but so the One the prayer is pointed to can be more fully known.
I’ll say it plainly.
I am a Christian. My Christology is higher than most of my friends’. I think Jesus is the image of the invisible God. I also think I have been wrong about almost everything I once held with certainty — and that has not disqualified me from the relationship. It has been the relationship.
You are not betraying the people who raised you in the faith. If you are letting a particular picture of certainty die, you are doing what every serious lover of God in this tradition has eventually had to do — let one picture die so the One it pointed to can be more fully known. Augustine did this. Aquinas did this. Luther did this. Wesley did this. A great many of the people who blessed you in your own life almost certainly did this, even if they never had vocabulary for it. You are not the first.
What’s left when certainty goes is what was supposed to be there the whole time.
Trust.
There’s a story in Luke about Jesus showing up on the road to Emmaus. Two disciples are walking and don’t recognize him. They proceed to tell him — him — everything that has just happened in Jerusalem. Their theology is so wrong they can’t recognize the risen Christ standing next to them. Jesus walks them through the scriptures, explains the whole thing. Their hearts are burning. They still don’t see it.
Then he breaks bread.
And in the breaking of the bread, they finally know him.
Not in the explanation. In the meal.
That was Christianity before it was about believing the right things.
It still is.
It is the encounter with a mystery that shows up in the embodied life — in the bread, in the water, in the room, in the body next to yours.
The relationship was never in the certainty. It was always in the meal.
What’s dying is real. What’s underneath it is older, deeper, and isn’t going anywhere.
You don’t have to know what you believe.
You just have to keep showing up.
For those of us who are Christians, the bread is still being broken. The invitation is still being given. Whether you are one of the women who stayed faithful to Jesus all the way to the end, or a disciple who denied him, abandoned him, or betrayed him — in this moment and the next, the invitation is still being given.
Pull up a chair.
Join Our New Online Class with Dr. Ilia Delio and Dr. Tripp Fuller
You haven’t lost your faith.
You’ve outgrown its container.
You’ve read the books. Asked the questions. Maybe deconstructed, maybe just drifted. The faith you inherited doesn’t fit anymore—but you’re not ready to throw it all away.
You’re not alone. And, you’re not broken.
What if the restlessness you feel isn’t a loss of faith but the growing pains of faith evolving? What if religion itself is going through exactly what you’re going through—and there’s a map for what comes next?
Dr. Ilia Delio (Franciscan sister, Villanova theologian, author of The Not-Yet God) and Dr. Tripp Fuller (founder of Homebrewed Christianity, process theologian, host of 1,500+ conversations with leading scholars) have spent decades on this question. Now they’re joining forces to trace religion’s evolutionary arc—and to invite you into what’s emerging.
Live Q&A sessions begin in May. Sign up now to join the conversation in real time—or watch the replays at your own pace.
WHAT IS INCLUDED?
4 Lectures: Pre-recorded video lectures you can watch on your own schedule—approximately 50 minutes each.
4 Live Sessions: Join Ilia and Tripp your questions in real time. Can’t make it live? Replays are available on the Class Resource Page.
Community Connection: Connect with fellow travelers in the class Facebook group. Share questions, resources, and aha moments throughout the four weeks.
ASYNCHRONOUS CLASS: You can participate fully without being present at any specific time. Replays are available on the Class Resource Page.
COST: A course like this is typically offered for $250 or more. Your contributions are what make our classes possible. We invite you to contribute whatever amount you feel led to give (including $0).
Join Dr. Ilia Delio at Theology Beer Camp 2026 - Will You Be There?
THEOLOGY BEER CAMP
October 8-10, 2026 - Kansas City, MO
Theology Beer Camp is a unique three-day conference that brings together of theology nerds and craft beer for a blend of intellectual engagement, community building, and fun. Organized by Homebrewed Christianity, this event features a lineup of well-known podcasters, scholars, and theology enthusiasts who come together to “nerd out” on theological topics while enjoying loads of fun activities.
Upgrade to Get Complete Access!
To support the work of Tripp Fuller and Homebrewed Christianity, please consider becoming a paid subscriber of the Process This Substack to get access to ad-free podcasts, members only reading groups, and more!
