This is the fourth live Q&A for The Christ Empire Couldn’t Keep, and this week we’re in the Americas with Bartolomé de las Casas — Joerg’s pick over Martin Luther for the Reformation-era chapter, and the hinge of the whole course. Here’s why. Las Casas owned an encomienda. He had Native people working for him. He was, in Joerg’s words, a slave driver. Then he woke up, gave the land away, freed the people, and spent the rest of his life arguing against the conquest. Gustavo Gutiérrez read him as a precursor to liberation theology, and when Joerg got into the sources, he thought: not so fast. Because what Las Casas actually represents is the pivot from empire hard to empire soft — from fire and sword to kindness and charity, which is nicer, preferable, and still empire. The whole session is about learning to tell soft empire from the way of Christ when they look almost identical. We got the charity/advocacy/solidarity distinction, the flip on anthropology (not others are like us but what if I were like them), why converting from one God to another is harder than converting from no God at all, why land back needs labor back alongside it, and Joerg’s answer to the flag-wrapped warrior Christ, which is two words long.
Highlights from the conversation
The pivot: empire hard to empire soft. Leopold’s opening question on why Las Casas is the hinge. Rome was harsh in its provinces. The Norman Conquest was harsh. And here is the moment somebody wakes up and says we cannot keep converting people with fire and the sword. Las Casas’s own book was titled The Only Way — the way of Christ in mission, as against the Spanish methods. Joerg’s warning: the Northern European liberals of the nineteenth century pick up this softer discourse, which is why next week’s Schleiermacher session matters. This is not a Catholic-Protestant story. It’s the birth of the empire we’re actually living in.
Charity, advocacy, solidarity. Xavier’s question on how to tell soft empire from the way of Christ when they look alike. Joerg’s rule of thumb. Charity has something patronizing in it — here, let me help you, let me give you a handout, because I’m the one in control. Advocacy — the liberal move — functions the same way: I speak for those who have no voice. Better than silence, and still top-down. Solidarity asks a different question entirely: how are those of us closer to the center of the empire actually related to those pushed under its wheels? That’s the way forward, and it’s where the class is heading in two weeks.
Flip the measuring stick. Caleb’s question, and the Christological core of the hour. Well-meaning people tell their kids others are people like us — which is real progress from they’re three-fifths human. The problem is you’re still the paradigm. You determine what human means and are then generous enough to include others in it. Joerg’s flip: what if others define us? Not others are like me, but what if I were like them? Which is exactly the Chalcedonian question about Christ’s humanity — Jesus is homoousios hemin, of the same substance as us, and the whole thing depends on who gets to define humanity. A. J. Levine on Jesus the Jew helps, and Joerg pushes further: Jesus was a specific kind of Jew who challenged Judaism too, because he was looking from below. The last shall be first. What you have done to the least of these.
What gets lost when suffering and agency get split. Adam’s question. Las Casas finds the suffering Christ in the Natives — genuinely striking, and Gutiérrez rightly celebrates it. He calls them the Christs of the Indies. But then he locates the acting Christ in the Spaniards. Which is the charity problem again: some people act, others receive. Joerg on what good news to the poor actually means — not that we bring them a hot meal, but that you will no longer be poor, which is about agency as much as money. And the solution isn’t a middle road where everybody gets a little agency and a little suffering. Agency emerges in the struggle. Like Good Friday and Easter, which we keep splitting apart: victory through defeat, agency built through suffering.
Converting from one God to another. Pete’s question, and the hardest thing in the session. We usually picture conversion as unbelief to belief. Joerg’s experience: church is the hardest place to talk about God, because most people think God is the one thing they already know — you can do a history study, you can do mission work, but the God thing you cannot touch. And if you can’t question your images of God, it may be that you’re worshiping an idol. Las Casas wakes up not through argument but through practice, through blood and sweat and death. George Bernard Shaw: God created humanity in his image, and we have returned the favor. Which means the image at stake isn’t just my self-image but my image of how the world works. Convert the churches first. That’s what Jesus was doing — not pointing fingers at outsiders, but working on his own people.
The privilege/power distinction, and what Wink missed. Sarah asked about Walter Wink and the powers. Joerg thinks highly of him, and names what he’s pushing past. Wink analyzes dominant power well. The harder question is how do we fit into it — those of us who aren’t the violent perpetrators, who mean well, who think that by criticizing the conquest we’re home free. Joerg’s move: privilege and power get confused. He has plenty of privilege and says so. But privilege doesn’t translate into power, which is why speaking truth to power isn’t sufficient, and why you have to organize. George Tinker’s Missionary Conquest (1993) tells four centuries of stories where missionaries contributed to genocide of Native populations without benefiting themselves — agents of the empire who weren’t driving it or profiting from it. Once you see that discrepancy, you can fight back.
Land back needs labor back. Isaac’s question on reparations. Las Casas said the Spanish needed restitution of what was wrongfully taken or they’d lose their souls, which Joerg takes straight: reparations are necessary, saying sorry doesn’t cut it (see last week on the weight of sin). But then the thing nobody’s talking about. Everybody’s talking about land. What else was Las Casas taking? Labor. Forty acres and a mule — what’s the mule for? Land can go in a trust; labor is what you do every day, and it’s where agency lives. The conclusions of Theology in the Capitalocene work this out for reparations for enslavement in the US, in terms of both land and labor. (There’s an excerpt in Jacobin, and a version at YES! Magazine — Google his name plus reparations.)
On the flag-wrapped warrior Christ: just say no. Celeste’s question about cowboy Jesus. Joerg reached, of all places, for Nancy Reagan. There’s nothing else to say. This is the hardest thing for his Methodist students, because the instinct is to be welcoming and hospitable and all-inclusive. So he reads them the actual invitation to the United Methodist open table: Christ our Lord invites all who love him, who earnestly repent of their sin, and want to live in peace with one another. If you do not repent, and you do not want to live in peace with one another, you are not invited. The words idolatry and heresy are on the table.
About our guest
Dr. Joerg Rieger is the Distinguished Professor of Theology and the Cal Turner Chancellor’s Chair of Wesleyan Studies at Vanderbilt University and founding director of the Wendland-Cook Program in Religion and Justice. For three decades, he has worked to bring together theology and the struggles for justice and liberation that mark our age. His work addresses relations of theology and public life, reflecting on the misuse of power in religion, politics, and economics. His interest is in movements that bring about change and in the positive contributions of religion and theology. His constructive work in theology draws on a wide range of historical and contemporary traditions, with a concern for manifestations of the divine in the pressures of everyday life. Several of his 24 authored and edited books address the topics of this course, including No Rising Tide: Theology, Economics, and the Future; Unified We Are a Force: How Faith and Labor Can Overcome America’s Inequalities (with Rosemarie Henkel-Rieger); and Faith, Class, and Labor: Intersectional Approaches in a Global Context (with Jin Young Choi). www.joergrieger.com
Previous Episodes w/ Joerg
Anselm’s God Can’t Just Forgive: Joerg Rieger on Why That’s Good News, Not Cruelty
Who Owns the Creed? Joerg Rieger on the Conservative Gimmick and the Surplus They Missed
Empire Goes All the Way Down: Joerg Rieger on What “Christian Nationalism” Misses
Wild Goose Theology Happy Hour with Joerg Rieger and Emilie Townes
Occupy the Church! Rita Nakashima Brock, Joerg Rieger, & Christophe Ringer
JOIN OUR OPEN ONLINE CLASS:
The Empire Christ Couldn’t Keep
Ever notice how Christian nationalism gets talked about like it’s some bizarre new glitch in the faith? It isn’t — it’s a 2,000-year-old arrangement wearing new clothes, and once you see how the pattern works, you can also spot the Christ who keeps slipping free of it. Join theologian Joerg Rieger and Tripp Fuller for The Christ Empire Couldn’t Keep, a free six-week online class tracing the holy alliances, imperial creeds, and stubborn resistance that have shaped Christianity from Paul to the present. You’ll get six lectures from Joerg, six live Q&As, weekly readings from his book Christ and Empire, and a community of fellow troublemakers thinking it through together.
It’s free to join, every session is recorded, and it kicks off Thursday, August 27. Grab your spot at HomebrewedClasses.com.
Highlights from the conversation
Empire goes all the way down. Mark’s question: what does “empire” as conglomerates of power seeking to control all of life let us see that “Christian nationalism” by itself misses? Joerg’s answer starts with the empire cults. He was taught they were a thin religious veneer on top of the political order — Constantine faking it. He doesn’t think that’s true. The imperial cults were ways of life, defining how people lived all the way to the core. Which means Christian nationalism isn’t just a belief system either, and it shapes you whether you subscribe to it or not. Tripp’s addition, via Jan-Olav Henriksen: the engine of religion is orientation and transformation, and the theology is just the tip of the iceberg. Our Reformation inheritance keeps assuming that if we fix the ideas, the material relations follow. They don’t.
The German word that clarified the whole project. Devon asked about the translation problem, and it’s the best window into the book. German offers two options for surplus: Überfluss, abundance, and Mehrwert, the surplus value produced by working people. Joerg’s translator asked which one. Choosing the second changes everything. Nobody eats food that falls from the sky — there’s labor in it. So why do we assume theology drops from above, or from some great theologian’s mind for everyone else to copy? The theological surplus is a question about production: where are alternative theological ideas actually made? Which means the gaze goes down and around instead of up. Burning bush, not a voice from the sky. Jesus born to a construction day-laborer. The incarnation isn’t up there. It’s here.
Paul is not a conservative. He is also not a liberal. Harold’s question, and the sharpest exchange of the hour. The liberal move would have been picking a safer title than Lord — finding terms that don’t ruffle feathers, making distinctions about religion so it doesn’t get offensive. That wasn’t Paul’s world, where a modern separation of religion and politics wouldn’t have parsed. And the cost of the evasion isn’t irrelevance, though the church is seeing plenty of that. It’s worse: by trying to stay out of it, you get pulled in. You become part of what drives the problem. Joerg’s related read on the ambiguity inside the New Testament itself — Galatians, then Ephesians softening, then the Pastorals fully reinstating the Roman household structure — is the same slippery slope that took Methodism from Wesley naming exactly why poor people are poor to buying organs and becoming respectable within a generation of his death.
What happens to the middle when the right keeps moving right. Tamika, from a self-described progressive mainline church, asked where “surely we can all get along” lands if there are only two flows of power. Joerg’s answer is geometric and brutal. When the book was written, people were alarmed about empire under George W. Bush. That was child’s play. If the right keeps moving right, the middle moves with it — and people who think of themselves as moderates end up somewhere a European observer wouldn’t recognize as moderate at all. His closing example, as a German Methodist: staying neutral and hanging in the middle is exactly what the German Methodist Church thought it was doing between 1933 and 1945, and it discovered afterward that it had become part of the problem.
Logic, not morality — and what that does to Bonhoeffer. Kenny asked what changes if the problem is Rome’s logic rather than Rome’s morality. Three things: you develop a systemic analysis, you stop demonizing individual bad actors, and — critically — you stop waiting for the upstanding moral hero. Joerg’s line for his students: if you speak truth to power, the problem is you may well have the truth, but they still have the power. Which reframes Bonhoeffer. Not as a failure, but as someone who got into the logic and stayed too aloof — a product of the Bildungsbürgertum, killed before forty, never able to move fully into solidarity with working people. Tripp’s addition from After Ten Years: the shift right at the end, when the relational hermeneutic finally gets its material side, and Christ is found standing alongside the least of these. Joerg pushes it one notch further: not church forothers, but church with others. That small preposition is exactly the move from morality to logic — because solidarity pushed by morality burns people out.
Essential workers, and the recognition that didn’t survive. Lucas noticed the line from the lecture: the pandemic gave us a phrase very close to Paul’s indispensable members, and the phrase outlived the recognition. Joerg’s read is that this is not forgetfulness. It’s active. When Paul insisted on the invisible members of the body, he had to make a big point precisely because the system was working to make them more invisible. Same now. Churches went to grocery stores and applauded and handed out little presents — and almost nothing came of the deeper realization, which is that a CEO can CEO all day and nothing appears on the shelves, while without the food and agricultural and grocery workers the shelves are empty and so is your stomach. There are always more of us who work for a living than of them who don’t.
Dr. Joerg Rieger is the Distinguished Professor of Theology and the Cal Turner Chancellor’s Chair of Wesleyan Studies at Vanderbilt University and founding director of the Wendland-Cook Program in Religion and Justice. For three decades, he has worked to bring together theology and the struggles for justice and liberation that mark our age. His work addresses relations of theology and public life, reflecting on the misuse of power in religion, politics, and economics. His interest is in movements that bring about change and in the positive contributions of religion and theology. His constructive work in theology draws on a wide range of historical and contemporary traditions, with a concern for manifestations of the divine in the pressures of everyday life. Several of his 24 authored and edited books address the topics of this course, including No Rising Tide: Theology, Economics, and the Future; Unified We Are a Force: How Faith and Labor Can Overcome America’s Inequalities (with Rosemarie Henkel-Rieger); and Faith, Class, and Labor: Intersectional Approaches in a Global Context (with Jin Young Choi). www.joergrieger.com
Previous Episodes w/ Joerg
Wild Goose Theology Happy Hour with Joerg Rieger and Emilie Townes
Occupy the Church! Rita Nakashima Brock, Joerg Rieger, & Christophe Ringer
Theology Beer Camp Online: TBC26 FM Edition
Theology Beer Camp is less than 2 months away and if you’re not coming to Kansas City, I get it. Flights are expensive, the world is ending, your dog has opinions about being boarded.
Here’s the good news: Theology Beer Camp is coming to you instead.
Online tickets for TBC26-FM are live. Join us online by clicking here.
And get this – the online experience has been upgraded!
We built a whole live podcast stage this year, which means you now get TWO live feeds to bounce between all weekend. Hop between the Main Stage with all our keynoters and the live God-pod stage, which surprisingly offers nonstop podcast excitement. Watch one, watch the other, get FOMO about both simultaneously. It’s a very spiritual experience.
Oh, and it’s all recorded and available for replay, along with the recordings from the three stages.
30 scholars. 30 God-pods. October 8-10. (One month before the election, which we did not plan and are choosing to interpret as prophecy.)
What you’ll need to supply yourself: the beer, the snacks, and a plausible reason for why you’re crying (or shouting) at a podcast recording on a Saturday morning. Everything else is handled.
Sorry we cannot livestream you a hug from a stranger in a Battlestar Galactica shirt, but we’ll see you on the frequency,
Tripp
P.S. The in-person ticket may get you Kansas City, but the online ticket gets you the same great content and your sweatpants. We’ll let you do the math.















